Critics highlight the 2023 release as a return to classic Napa finesse with Bordeaux-style freshness. The extended harvest window allowed for complete phenolic maturity without overripe or cooked fruit notes. It is approachable early due to its satiny tannins but possesses the structure to age gracefully through 2050 and beyond.  

Antonio Galloni (Vinous) 98 points Brisk acidity, red/purplish fruit, mint, orange peel, chalk; exquisite lightness with indescribable class.
Decanter 98  points  Cool blue fruit, cocoa powder, crunchy red cherry, blackberry, fine-knit tannins, and a mineral/graphite finish.
Jeb Dunnuck 98 points   Cassis, black raspberries, spicy wood, and graphite; nuanced bouquet with a 30–40 year drinking window.